search this site.

131214P - ALZAHRAWI’S HOLISTIC VIEW OF HEALTH AND DISEASE: RELEVANCE IN THE CONTEMPORARY HEALTH DISCOURSE: AN ISLAMIC PERSPECTIVE AL ZAHRAWI AND THE ISLAMIC WORLD VIEW

Print Friendly and PDFPrint Friendly



Paper written by Professor Omar Hasan Kasule Sr. MB ChB(MUK), MPH (Harvard), DrPH (Harvard)


FATHER OF MODERN SURGERY
·         Abu al-Qasim Khalaf ibn al-Abbas Al-Zahrawi (936–1013G) is the father of modern surgery
·         Kitab al-Tasrif li man ‘ajaza ‘an al ta’aliif, a 30-volume encyclopedia of medical practices completed in 1000G; 50 years of experience. First illustrated medical book.  Published in Lucknow in 1908G.
·         A;Zahrawi’s surgical procedures and instruments are still applied in medicine today (?plagiarism / intellectual property?)
·         We should not be complacent with the achievements of the past. AlZahrawi inspires us to write the future while reading our history.
·         Innovative and creative. Combination of reading the 2 books ‘kitaab al wahy’ and ‘kitaab al kawn’

AMONG FIRSTS OF ALZAHRAWI
·         Description of ectopic pregnancy, cervical dilatation
·         Identification of the hereditary nature of haemophilia[1],
·         Description of a surgical procedure for ligating the temporal artery for migraine
·         evacuation of hydrocephalus[2]
·         Use of catgut for internal stitching is still practised in modern surgery

SURGICAL INSTRUMENTS
·         Inspection of urethral interior
·         Rremoving foreign bodies from the throat
·         Inspection of the ear
·         Cannulas
·         Hooks with a double tip for surgery
·         Use of forceps in vaginal deliveries and extraction of dead fetus

FIRSTS NOT CREDITED
·         Because of limited translations into modern western languages Al Zahrawi’s achievements were not widely known[3]
·         "Kocher's method" for treating a dislocated shoulder
·         "Walcher position" in obstetrics.
·         No charges of plagiarism / violation of intellectual property were made

PERSONAL DIMENSION
·         Positive doctor-patient relationship
·         Affectionate with his students, whom he referred to as "my children"
·         Emphasized the importance of treating patients irrespective of their social status.
·         Encouraged the close observation of individual cases in order to make the most accurate diagnosis and the best possible treatment.
·         The historian AlHumaidhi in his book ‘jadhwat al muqtabas fi akhbaar ulamaa al andalus’ that AlZahrawi was religious.
·         He was known to set aside half of the day to treat the poor for free

WHAT MADE ALZHRAWI GREAT? evidence-based medicine
·         Two lessons from AlZahrawi: empirical evidence-based knowledge (hujjiyat al burhan/daliil) and a holistic approach to medicine (shumuliyyat)
·         AlZahrawi was a great researcher and based his work on empirical evidence.
·         Insisted on dissection.
·         In the introduction to tasrif he said that the book contained what he experiences and tried out in 50 years.
·         Muslims inspired by the Qur’an to follow daliil and burhan and to look in the universes around them for signs of Allah, ayat al Allah fi al kawn

WHAT MADE ALZHRAWI GREAT? holistic medicine
·         AlZahrawi worked within the shummuli / holistic context of Islam.
·         Islam is a complete system with guidelines for all aspects of life
·         The guidelines are general conceptual principles leaving a lot of room for human effort by ijtihad to extend the frontiers of knowledge
·         Holism or shumuliyat are based on tauhid

TAUHID: INTRODUCTION
·         Tauhid encapsulates the integrative Islamic world view, tasawwur islami
·         The monotheistic creed, ‘aqidat al tauhid: Oneness of God, tauhid al dhaat; Oneness of creation, tauhid al rubuubiyyat, &oneness of worship, tauhid al uluhiyyat.
·         Tauhid has implications for our daily life based on issuing from one creator: brotherhood and equality, consistent and harmonious physical, social, economic, political laws as well as holistic medical care.
·         Tauhid provides a paradigmatic basis for resolving problem/crisis of duality of knowledge, azmatizdiwajiyat al ma’arifat, towards integration of knowledge, takamul al ma’arifat
·         Tauhid provides a paradigm for research, teaching, and practice of basic medical sciences, clinical sciences, and medical professionalism

TAUHID: EPISTEMOLOGICAL IMPLICATIONS
·         Knowledge crisis = dichotomy in the education system: traditional Islamic vs. imported European. Students and their teachers are confused by the contradictory world-views presented by the two systems
·         The mission of the knowledge strategy is conceptual transformation of the education system from kindergarten to post graduate studies to reflect the tauhidicintegrative paradigm, positive moral values, objectivity, universality, and serving the larger causes of humanity.
·         Many efforts towards an integrated education system are acknowledged such as IIIT, IIUM, other Islamic universities, FWCII etc: there are conceptual & practical problems not yet resolved but we have come a long way.

TAUHID: BIOLOGICAL IMPLICATIONS
·         Tauhid explains the perfection, optimality, order, harmony, consistency, co-ordination, and purposive ness and of body structure and physiology
·         Tauhid explains the consistency of the physical and social laws, sunan al kawn, that underlie biological phenomena of order (thabaat) and change (taghyiir) such as homeostasis and negative feedback in human physiology referable to the Qur’anic concepts of balance (mizan), equilibrium (e’itidal), and action-reaction (tadafu’u)
·         The purpose of scientific research is to discover (basic science) and exploit (technology) the sunan al kawn
·         Study of biology reveals signs of Allah (ayatkawniyyat) in biology: perfection (kamal al khalq), incomparability (‘azj al shurakaa), functional unity (C-C-C) based on the nervous and endocrine systems to be read alongside Qur’anic signs (ayatqur’aniyyat)

TAUHID: REJECTION OF MATERIALISM IN MEDICINE
·         Health is holistic including spiritual health, physical health, psychological and mental health, and social health all properly balanced. The human body as integrated physiological entity that all suffers if any part is injured.
·         The biomedical model (BMM) in modern medicine was characterized by focus on: the physical and rejection of the psychosocial and spiritual, disease and not illness, disease and not health, quantity and not quality of life, organ pathology and not the whole patient.
·         BMM commodizes health, medicalizes life, demystifies the human body, dehumanizes the patient as a machine, depersonalizes the patient as a pathology, and lacks balance and equilibrium,

TAUHID: PARADIGM SHIFT: THE BIOMEDICAL TO THE HOLISTIC
  • Lack of integration due to atomistic view of the cosmos: analytic but not synthetic
  • Integration is not addition but is fitting according to the laws, sunan
·         Tauhid motivates the shift from the biomedical to the holistic model that looks at thepatient, the disease, and the environment as one system that is in equilibrium;
·         Tauhid motivates looking at a patient as one organism and not a convenient combination of organs and pathologies. The patient has physical, social, psychological, and spiritual dimensions that have to be considered together in an integrated, holistic, and balanced fashion.

TAUHIDI and HOLISTIC MEDICINE (HM)
·         HM is defined as medicine that focuses on the ‘whole person’ and not the malady itself.  It considers physical, social, psychological, and spiritual aspects of disease
·         It was the mainstream form of medicine in all ages (Islamic medicine, unani medicine)  until marginalized by scientific medicine to become a form of alternative medicine
·         Integrative medicine is when a physician of modern medicine integrates a holistic approach
·         Return to holistic medicine is return to tauhidi medicine

TAJDID & ISLAH
·         This ummat experiences periods of growth and periods of decline but it always rises up
·         There is a renewal in each century. This renewal is based on reform of knowledge and education

REFERENCES