search this site.

120430L - DISCUSSIONS ON RESEARCH ETHICS

Print Friendly and PDFPrint Friendly



Lecture by Prof Omar Hasan Kasule Sr. for 4th year medical students at the Faculty of Medicine KFMC Riyadh on April 30, 2012


1.0 GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS (A)
1.      What is the moral justification for non-therapeutic research
2.      Discuss issues relating to inclusiveness.
3.      Explain the concept of clinical equipoise
4.      Should hospitals reject all research sponsored by pharmaceutical companies?
5.      Is research based on putting fluorine or iodine in public water ethical?
6.      What are the duties and responsibilities of a patient in research?
7.      Is innovative surgery considered a form of research?  
8.      Is it proper to include a placebo group in a drug trial in the third for a drug licensed in the rich countries?

2.0 GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS (B)
9.      Describe various forms of fraud in research
10.  Describe methods of avoiding research malpractices
11.  Is it proper for a physician to charge a finder's fee for suggesting his patients to be invited as research subjects? Is it proper for a physician to be paid to enroll patients? Should researchers take money and other benefits from pharmaceutical companies that sponsor research?
12.  Is research ethical in poor countries for the benefit of rich countries? Discuss the 10/90 gap: 10% of research money is spent on 90% of the world's health problems. Explain how patenting restricts access to drugs by poor countries

3.0 INFORMED CONSENT and CONFIDENTIALITY (A)
1.      Explain the application of the principle of autonomy in clinical research
2.      List information items that patients involved in clinical research must be told
3.      Explain how informed consent helps protect the patient. Explain why informed consent in clinical research is more important than in normal patient treatment.
4.      Is self interest a valid reason for patient consent to participate in research? Is a patient obliged to participate in clinical research in the public interest?  Can the patient be forced to be part of the research if the research drug s the same as the drug he takes normally for his disease? Why should a terminal patient participate in a drug toxicity study? Is it proper to offer poor patients participation in research so that they can have access to expensive drugs?

4.0 INFORMED CONSENT and CONFIDENTIALITY (B)
5.      What measures would you take if a research subject says 'I do not understand this research but I will sign anyway because I trust you'
6.      Explain ethico-legal guidelines on withdrawal from research at any time.
7.      Is it ethical to undertake research  in the emergency room without informed consent
8.      Explain the application of confidentiality in clinical research
9.      What do you do if in the course of your research you discover a sexually transmitted disease unrelated to the subject of your research?
10.  What do you do if the course of your questionnaire research on cardiovascular disease you discover severe mental disease in an airline pilot?

5.0 RESEARCH ON HUMAN TISSUES (A)
1.      Describe ethico-legal guidelines on genetic testing of biological samples obtained from individuals (hint: informed consent must be obtained if the test is not anonymized).
2.      Describe ethico-legal guidelines on research on material from living donors
3.      Describe ethico-legal guidelines on research on material from deceased donors.
4.      Describe ethico-legal issues in research on tissues from aborted fetuses.
5.      Discuss dissection of cadavers for research or educational purposes

6.0 RESEARCH ON HUMAN TISSUES (B)
6.      Discuss what to do when a pregnant woman dies with a dead fetus in utero
7.      Discuss ethico-legal issues in embalming a dead body
8.      Discuss ethico-legal issues in post mortem examination for educational / research purposes
9.      Describe 2 sources of embryos for research and explain the difference in ethical consideration between them
10.  List research that requires use of embryos
11.  Explain ethical guidelines on research on fetal tissue
12.  Discuss comparative ethical issues in research on different types of stem: embryonal, fetal, cord, and adult
13.  Discuss genetic research involving genetic engineering

7.0 CONTROVERSIAL ISSUES IN HUMAN RESEARCH
1.      Discuss ethico-legal issues of pharmacogenomc research
2.      Discuss ethico-legal issues of research on ageing, longevity, and immortality
3.      Discuss ethico-legal issues of research on enhancement technologies,
4.      Discuss ethico-legal issues of research on psychosurgery,
5.      Discuss ethico-legal issues of research on neuro-transplantation,
6.      Discuss ethico-legal issues of research on gonadal transplantation,
7.      Discuss ethico-legal issues of research on xenotransplantation

8.0 RESEARCH ON THE VULNERABLE
1.      Explain ethico-legal guidelines on consent to research by mentally incompetent persons
2.      Explain ethico-legal guidelines on consent to research on children
3.      Discuss ethico-legal issues in research on women
4.      Discuss ethico-legal issues in research on the elderly
5.      Research on prisoners 
6.      Research on students 
7.      Research on employees 
8.      Research on members of uniformed services
9.      Discuss the obligation of members of the armed forces to be research subjects without consent