search this site.

210223P - DISCUSSIONS ON RESEARCH ETHICS

Print Friendly and PDFPrint Friendly

Presentation at a Research Methodology Course for Pediatrics Residency Program held via Zoom at Prince Sultan Military Medical City on 23 February 2021

 

1.0 GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS (A)

· What is the moral justification for non-therapeutic research
· Discuss issues relating to inclusiveness.
· Explain the concept of clinical equipoise
· Should hospitals reject all research sponsored by pharmaceutical companies?
· Is research based on putting fluorine or iodine in public water ethical?
· What are the duties and responsibilities of a patient in research?
· Is innovative surgery considered a form of research?   
· Is it proper to include a placebo group in a drug trial in the third for a drug licensed in the rich countries?

 

2.0 GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS (B)

· Describe various forms of fraud in research

· Describe methods of avoiding research malpractices

· Is it proper for a physician to charge a finder's fee for suggesting his patients be invited as research subjects? Is it proper for a physician to be paid to enroll patients? Should researchers take the money and other benefits from pharmaceutical companies that sponsor research?

· Is research ethical in poor countries for the benefit of rich countries? Discuss the 10/90 gap: 10% of research money is spent on 90% of the world's health problems. Explain how patenting restricts access to drugs by poor countries

 

3.0 INFORMED CONSENT and CONFIDENTIALITY (A)

· Explain the application of the principle of autonomy in clinical research

· List information items that patients involved in clinical research must be told

· Explain how informed consent helps protect the patient. Explain why informed consent in clinical research is more important than in normal patient treatment.

· Is self-interest a valid reason for patient consent to participate in research? Is a patient obliged to participate in clinical research in the public interest?  Can the patient be forced to be part of the research if the research drug s the same as the drug he takes normally for his disease? Why should a terminal patient participate in a drug toxicity study? Is it proper to offer poor patients participation in research so that they can have access to expensive drugs?

 

4.0 INFORMED CONSENT and CONFIDENTIALITY (B)

· What measures would you take if a research subject says 'I do not understand this research but I will sign anyway because I trust you.'

· Explain ethico-legal guidelines on withdrawal from research at any time.

· Is it ethical to undertake research in the emergency room without informed consent?

· Explain the application of confidentiality in clinical research

· What do you do if, in the course of your research, you discover a sexually transmitted disease unrelated to the subject of your research?

· What do you do if the course of your questionnaire research on cardiovascular disease you discover severe mental disease in an airline pilot?

 

5.0 RESEARCH ON HUMAN TISSUES (A)

· Describe ethico-legal guidelines on genetic testing of biological samples obtained from individuals (hint: informed consent must be obtained if the test is not anonymized).

· Describe ethico-legal guidelines on research on material from living donors

· Describe ethico-legal guidelines on research on material from deceased donors.

· Describe ethico-legal issues in research on tissues from aborted fetuses.

· Discuss dissection of cadavers for research or educational purposes

 

6.0 RESEARCH ON HUMAN TISSUES (B)

· Discuss what to do when a pregnant woman dies with a dead fetus in utero

· Discuss ethico-legal issues in embalming a dead body

· Discuss ethico-legal issues in post-mortem examination for educational / research purposes

· Describe 2 sources of embryos for research and explain the difference in ethical consideration between them

· List research that requires the use of embryos

· Explain ethical guidelines for research on fetal tissue

· Discuss comparative ethical issues in research on different types of stem: embryonal, fetal, cord, and adult

· Discuss genetic research involving genetic engineering

 

7.0 CONTROVERSIAL ISSUES IN HUMAN RESEARCH

· Discuss ethico-legal issues of pharmacogenomic research

· Discuss ethico-legal issues of research on aging, longevity, and immortality

· Discuss ethico-legal issues of research on enhancement technologies,

· Discuss ethico-legal issues of research on psychosurgery,

· Discuss ethico-legal issues of research on neuro-transplantation,

· Discuss ethico-legal issues of research on gonadal transplantation,

· Discuss ethico-legal issues of research on xenotransplantation

 

8.0 RESEARCH ON THE VULNERABLE

· Explain ethico-legal guidelines on consent to research by mentally incompetent persons

· Explain ethico-legal guidelines on consent to research children

· Discuss ethico-legal issues in research on women

· Discuss ethico-legal issues in research on the elderly

· Research on prisoners 

· Research on students 

· Research on employees 

· Research on members of uniformed services

· Discuss the obligation of members of the armed forces to be research subjects without consent